dunsurfin wrote:under the "sale of goods, implied terms" act in the UK, he will be able to argue that the laptop is not fit for the purpose for which it was purchased.
Not a UK atty, but a US atty, but more than likely this would fall under the "implied warranty of merchantability", not "fit for a particular purpose". (Provided that this UK act is close in many was to the UNCITRAL uniform commerical codes). Merchantability means generally without manufacturing defects and would "pass without objection in the trade". "Fit for a particular purpose" would mean that it is not usable in a particular function for which it was intended. For the laptop to function at all, the screen needs to work. If this were say a touchscreen that was malfunctioning as a touchscreen (but otherwise functional) that would more than likely breach the warranty of fit for a particular purpose. The difference really only matters to lawyers.
/legal mumbo jumbo